In a significant judgment, the Supreme Court of Pakistan has overturned the dismissal of Malik Muhammad Ramzan, restoring his employment after a ten-year legal struggle. The apex court not only reinstated him but also ordered his promotion and the payment of all pending dues for the last decade.
The ruling came under Civil Petition No. 2768-L/2022, challenging the Punjab Service Tribunal’s decision dated January 24, 2022.
Violation of Legal Procedure
A three-member bench headed by Justice Aqeel Ahmed Abbasi, and comprising Justice Musarrat Hilali and Justice Mian Gul Hassan Aurangzeb, found serious violations of Sections 9 and 10 of the Punjab Employees Efficiency, Discipline and Accountability (PEEDA) Act 2006 during departmental proceedings.
The court noted that no show-cause notice was issued to Ramzan, nor was he given a fair opportunity to defend himself during the inquiry — a clear breach of the principles of natural justice.
Background of the Case
In 2016, the District Coordination Officer (DCO) Mianwali accused Ramzan of embezzlement and forgery involving cheque transactions. He was dismissed from service on February 29, 2016.
His departmental appeal and review petition were both rejected, and in 2022, the Punjab Service Tribunal upheld his dismissal. He then approached the Supreme Court for relief.
During this time, Ramzan was also acquitted in a criminal case filed by the Anti-Corruption Department on the same allegations.
Court’s Observations
The Supreme Court found that during the inquiry, Ramzan was in police custody (January 19–June 30, 2016) and was never served a show-cause notice.
The inquiry officer, Ghulam Mustafa Sheikh — who was also the complainant in the anti-corruption case — admitted in his statement on June 1, 2024, that he had neither conducted any investigation against Ramzan nor issued any notice.
Furthermore, the court noted that the disputed cheque was never sent for handwriting expert verification and questioned why no departmental action was taken against the inquiry officer himself.
Order of Reinstatement and Promotion
Setting aside the tribunal’s verdict, the Supreme Court ordered the department to:
- Reinstate Malik Muhammad Ramzan immediately.
- Promote him according to his service tenure.
- Release all pending dues, including salaries and allowances for the last ten years.
If the department deems it necessary to re-investigate the allegations, the court directed that the process must comply with PEEDA Act Sections 9 and 10, ensuring full opportunity for defence, and must be completed within three months.
Legal Significance
The judgment referenced earlier cases — Nasib Khan v. Divisional Superintendent Pakistan Railways (2008 SCMR 1369) and Raja Muhammad Shahid v. Inspector General of Police (2023 SCMR 1135) — which established that major penalties such as dismissal require a proper inquiry and the right to defend oneself.
This ruling reinforces transparency and due process in departmental proceedings, strengthening protections for civil servants.
Public Reaction
Speaking after the verdict, Malik Muhammad Ramzan expressed deep gratitude to the Supreme Court, calling the decision a “victory of justice after ten years of struggle.” Legal experts hailed it as a precedent-setting ruling that highlights the importance of fairness in disciplinary actions against government employees.



