The Federal Constitutional Court has barred the Peshawar High Court from hearing MPO detention cases.
The bar runs until further orders.
It covers arrests under Section 3 of the Maintenance of Public Order Ordinance.
Which MPO detention cases are affected
The ones that matter most in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa right now.
Among the matters pending before the Peshawar High Court is the case of Sohail Afridi, the province’s non-functional chief minister, who has been held since the emergency was imposed on 11 October.
Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and Justice Aamer Farooq sat on the bench.
The practical effect deserves stating without ornament. A man detained without published charge now has no high court able to hear his challenge.
Preventive detention under the MPO requires no charge and no trial. The high court was the forum in which its lawfulness could be tested, and that forum has been closed.
The exchange in court suggests the bench was not unanimous in its comfort. “Will the high court not hear cases that come before it on a daily basis?” Justice Aamer Farooq asked.
The Chief Justice told counsel: “Read our order and then file your objections.”
That a judge on the bench raised the question is worth recording, because it is the obvious objection and it came from inside the court rather than outside it.
The order lands five days before the Peshawar High Court was due to hear petitions against governor’s rule in the province, on 10 November.
Whether those petitions are also caught by the bar has not been clarified, and they concern Article 245 and the dissolution of the assembly rather than MPO detention specifically.
This newspaper reported on 2 November that the Lahore High Court sought reports on three sisters of Imran Khan held under the same ordinance since September, after their 30-day orders were extended.
That case is in Lahore and is not covered by this order, so the same statute is now reviewable in one province and not in another.
The wider pattern is a court consolidating authority rapidly. The Federal Constitutional Court was created by the 27th Amendment, held on 2 November that Supreme Court judgments do not bind it, and ruled today that its own observations bind the Supreme Court.
Taking jurisdiction away from a high court in the same week completes a picture of a new institution establishing primacy over the existing ones.
This paper takes no position on the constitutional merits, which are genuinely contested. It records that the practical result is fewer forums in which a detention can be challenged.
What has not been published is the reasoning behind the bar, how long it will last, or what remedy is available to those currently detained.
Nor has any date been set for the objections the Chief Justice invited.
[Image: The Express Tribune].
Sources: The Express Tribune.
frontpage.dev’s AI newsroom produced this report. AI agents synthesized and fact-checked it from multiple sources, under human editorial oversight. Spotted an error or a concern? Email Editor-in-Chief Hamza at hamza@thepakistandaily.com.



