Saturday, November 14, 2026 · Petrol Rs 330 · USD/PKR 276.62 · Gold Rs 411636/tola
Breaking
Soul City Holds Grand Launch Event at Prime Pine Avenue Location ECO Council of Ministers Meets in Islamabad From Sunday Supreme Court Says Time Cannot Erase Inheritance Rights World Bank Approves $300m for Rural Sindh Water and Sanitation Development Levy of Up to 10pc on Petrol and Diesel Vehicles Weather and Saud Shakeel Save First Test for Pakistan Pakistan Urges End to Attacks on Gulf States at UN Petrol Price Cut to Rs330 as Diesel Holds at Rs360 Government Speeds Groundwork for Referendum on New Provinces Mari Reports Copper and Gold Discovery in Chagai Weekly Inflation Falls 0.46pc as Fuel Cuts Reach the Basket Four Killed as Bannu Police Repel Checkpoint Attack Primary Surplus Beats IMF Target as Provincial Tax Goal Is Missed KSE-100 Recovers 500 Points on Chagai Copper Find FAA Lifts Nationwide Ground Stop After Communications Failure Disrupts US Flights USCIRF Raises Religious Freedom Concerns Over Detention of Muslim Activist Sharjeel Imam COP31 Could Open New Chapter in Pakistan–Türkiye Climate and Disaster Cooperation: Turkish Expert Mehmet Ozken Pakistani Man Dies Within 14 Hours of Deportation From US, Family Demands Answers Sindh to Move Official Vehicles to Electric Reserves Hold at $26.84 Billion as Central Bank Holdings Rise
Pakistan

Balochistan Opposition and Dawn Warn Military-Only Response Is Failing; Call for Political Dialogue with Nationalist Stakeholders

As Prime Minister Shehbaz vows to press military operations in Balochistan, the provincial opposition and Pakistan's leading newspaper are warning that the security-first approach is not working. Dawn's July 10 editorial called military body counts an inadequate response to a sustained political insurgency, and said a viable dialogue process involving Baloch nationalist stakeholders with roots in the province is essential. Opposition voices in Balochistan have sounded the alarm over spiralling violence that successive military campaigns have failed to stop.

Balochistan Opposition and Dawn Warn Military-Only Response Is Failing; Call for Political Dialogue with Nationalist Stakeholders
(Dawn)

As the Prime Minister flew to Quetta to announce a continuation of military operations, Pakistan’s opposition voices in Balochistan and the country’s most authoritative editorial platform have delivered a contrasting verdict: the approach is not working and will not work without a parallel political process (Dawn editorial, July 10; Dawn).

Dawn’s July 10 editorial — headlined “Balochistan carnage” — said that the July 5-8 attacks, which killed 42 security personnel and civilians in three coordinated incidents, reflect a sustained operational capability on the part of armed groups that targeted police posts, civilian areas and military convoys simultaneously. “A viable dialogue and political process involving Baloch nationalists and other stakeholders with roots in the province is essential to bring peace to Balochistan,” the editorial stated, adding that military operations alone have not produced a reduction in the frequency or sophistication of attacks.

Opposition voices within Balochistan have made similar arguments. Political figures representing constituencies where disappearances, extrajudicial operations, and resource exploitation are lived realities have renewed calls for the government to open formal talks with Baloch nationalist parties and civil society — including those whose political positions stop well short of endorsing the BLA’s armed campaign but who nonetheless articulate the grievances that sustain the insurgency’s recruiting base.

The structural critique

Pakistan’s military operations in Balochistan have successfully degraded individual cells, neutralised commanders, and disrupted supply chains. What they have not done is change the political economy that produces new fighters. Balochistan’s resource wealth — natural gas, copper, gold, coal — flows to the federal government while the province’s poverty rate remains the highest in Pakistan. Enforced disappearances, which human rights organisations have documented in the thousands, generate sustained family-level grievances that outlast any single military campaign. The lack of genuine provincial autonomy in practice, despite constitutional provisions, means that Balochistan’s elected officials have limited ability to deliver what their constituents most need.

Against this backdrop, a political dialogue with Baloch nationalist parties — which do have a constituency, unlike the BLA, which is a proscribed armed group — would serve a different function than peace talks with the insurgency itself. It would create a legitimate political outlet for grievances that currently have no formal channel, and give provincial leaders a reason to invest in the state’s legitimacy rather than to remain passive in the face of alienation.

Whether the current government has the political will for such a process — which would require concessions that powerful security sector interests would resist — remains the central question.

Hamza Azhar SalamEditor — Hamza Azhar Salam · Write to us with suggestions or tips
Powered by: Frontpage.dev
WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com